Older adults and younger people talking around a dining table in a bright home

Photo by Sweet Life / Unsplash

Labour Shortages Explained: Why Healthcare and Care Work Can’t Fill Roles, and What It Does to Wages in 2027

Healthcare and care work can’t fill roles because demand for care is rising faster than the supply of trained workers, while fixed funding and employer power stop wages from rising enough to close the gap, so pay is likely to keep edging up in 2027 rather than jump. Advertisements stay open, agencies struggle to cover shifts, and families wait for support at home.

What Is a Labour Shortage?

In a competitive market, a shortage means that at the going wage, employers want to hire more workers than are willing to supply their labour. The typical solution to that is for the wage to be raised to increase the pool of workers, and for employers to be forced to economise until the market is cleared. Thus, if there is a constant shortage, then there is something preventing the wage from changing, such as fixed funding, a dominant market, or barriers to the supply of labour.

Why Is Demand for Care Workers Rising?

The demand for care workers is a derived demand: it comes from the demand for care itself, which rises as populations age. The US Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS) projects that home health and personal care aides will grow from 4.68 million jobs in 2025 to 5.52 million in 2035, an 18 per cent rise and about 847,300 new jobs, the largest numerical increase of any occupation. It also expects around 760,500 openings a year, most of them to replace workers who leave rather than to fill new posts.

In England, Skills for Care reports that the adult social care vacancy rate fell to 6.2 per cent in 2025/26, around 96,000 vacancies, and the lowest in a decade. While this is a positive step, the Care Quality Commission has identified that the previous level of 7% was approximately 3 times higher than that of the wider labour market. Also, as at March 2025, the level of vacancies in homecare was just over 10%, which is more than double that of the vacancy levels in care homes.

What Do Current Care Job Listings Show?

 A single large employer shows how this demand looks in practice. The listing page for united energy workers healthcare careers showed around 40 openings across 14 US states. They were mostly registered nurses, licensed practical nurses, case managers, care assistants, and coordinators, and many were field roles delivered in patients’ homes. Advertised pay for aide roles started in the high $20,000s, while registered nurse roles were advertised at considerably higher salaries, a reminder that skills and training command a premium. The page showed no remote positions, which is typical for hands-on care.

Why Is It Hard to Recruit Care Workers?

The supply of labour is slow to respond for several reasons.

  • Relative pay. The BLS median wage for home health and personal care aides was $35,800 in May 2025, compared with $50,980 for all occupations. A worker comparing jobs can often earn more elsewhere for less physical and emotional strain.
  • Training and entry rules. Many care roles require certification or approved training, which takes time and money, so supply cannot jump when demand rises.
  • High turnover. Skills for Care puts the turnover rate in the independent sector at 24.7 per cent in 2024/25, although many leavers move to other care jobs.
  • Falling international recruitment. Skills for Care reports that international recruits fell from 105,000 in 2023/24 to around 50,000 in 2024/25, removing a major source of new workers. Its latest figures show direct overseas recruits fell again to around 30,000 in 2025/26.
Trainees practising CPR and airway support on a training mannequin

Why Do Care Worker Wages Not Simply Rise?

Three ideas from economics help explain this. First, funding constraints. Much care work is paid for or commissioned by governments, so employers cannot freely raise prices to fund higher pay. Second, Baumol’s cost disease. Labour-intensive services such as personal care experience a slow rate of productivity growth, as one hour's worth of care cannot easily be performed at a faster rate than other jobs. Workers can move from low productivity areas to high productivity sectors, where there are higher wages. Therefore, employers of care will have to pay higher salaries to compete for workers as their wages increase at a slower pace than those working in other industries.

Third, monopsony, where a few employers dominate local hiring, can pay below the competitive wage because workers have fewer alternatives nearby. The theory is debated, and the evidence is mixed, but it offers one explanation for why shortages can persist at a given pay level.

Will Care Worker Wages Rise in 2027?

The data indicates that care work wages will continue to increase; however, it does not suggest that this will occur with an abrupt rise. There will continue to be growing demand, and because there is an ongoing process of replacing employees, employers must hire additional workers at a consistent level if they want to maintain current operations. Employers that improve conditions may do better: Skills for Care found that of the five factors that were found to be associated with greater levels of turnover, the two most important were competitive pay (42.2% turnover) and having a permanent contract rather than a zero-hours contract (14.4%). These are examples of how pay, hours and career path are all important to workers.

The rate at which wages are going up depends on how the funding decisions are made and if international recruitment continues to be available. If international recruitment is not available, domestic competition for workers will increase, creating an environment to increase wages.

What Do Care Shortages Show About Labour Markets?

Labour shortages in healthcare and care work are not a simple failure of the market. They reflect growing derived demand, slow supply, and constraints that keep wages from adjusting quickly. This example serves as a real-world demonstration of how the operation of markets will differ from what is depicted in textbooks. For employees and employers, it shows that wages and working conditions remain vital labour relations issues through the end of the year 2027.