A tablet and a desktop monitor showing a ticker graph typical for trading software. There's a notebook on the desk under the monitor showing some notes.

Photo by Jakub Żerdzicki / Unsplash

Switching Costs: Why Do Investors Stay With Expensive Trading Platforms?

Investors often stay with expensive trading platforms because moving their money involves switching costs, such as fees, paperwork, delays and time out of the market, that can feel larger than the savings a cheaper provider would bring.

What Are Switching Costs?

Switching costs are the expenses and effort a consumer faces when moving from one provider to another. Economists usually group these switching barriers into three types: procedural costs, such as time and paperwork; financial costs, such as fees or lost benefits; and relational costs, such as the discomfort of leaving a familiar provider.

In most markets, these costs are less significant than they are in investing. With investing, however, these costs can be substantial and influence investor behaviour. For this reason many investors continue to maintain their accounts at the initial point of entry, rather than seeking out less expensive alternatives.

Which Costs Make Moving Platforms Hard?

The most visible cost has been the exit fee, a charge for leaving a platform. Fees are not the only obstacle, though. Investors who move by selling their holdings and transferring cash may be out of the market for days or weeks, missing any gains during that period. Moving holdings directly, known as an in-specie transfer, avoids that risk but can take longer and involve more paperwork.

Tax wrappers add another layer. An Individual Savings Account (ISA) needs to be transferred between providers rather than withdrawn and paid back in, or the investor risks losing its tax-free status on that money. HMRC guidance requires cash ISA transfers to be completed within 15 business days, but that timetable does not cover stocks and shares ISAs.

The difficulty shows up in the data. When the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) published the interim findings of its investment platforms market study in July 2018, it found that around 7% of all consumers had tried to switch but failed to do so.

Why Does Inertia Keep Investors in Place?

Even when switching is straightforward, many investors do not do it. Inertia, the tendency to stay with an existing choice rather than actively change it, is common in financial products. Behavioural economists link it to status quo bias, one form of decision-making bias: people prefer to keep things as they are, even after a choice has stopped serving them well.

Platform charges make inertia costly because they are small and recurring. A difference of 0.3 percentage points in annual fees on a £20,000 portfolio is £60 a year, an amount easy to ignore. Because charges are taken every year from a growing balance, the gap widens over time, yet each year it rarely seems worth the effort of moving.

Comparing fees can also be tricky due to a variety of factors. In the interim report for 2018, the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) reported that it is challenging to comprehend and compare costs associated with electronic platforms. As a result, determining whether or not it is worth switching becomes more complicated. A dedicated comparison site like Trading Brokers can help here. It sets out providers’ charges, account types and transfer policies side by side, so investors can see the real cost of each option before they commit.

How Do Switching Costs Affect Competition?

When customers are reluctant to leave, providers face less pressure to cut prices or improve service for the customers they already have. Competition then focuses on attracting new accounts, often with introductory offers, while existing customers may pay more than they would in a market where moving was easy.

This weakens consumer sovereignty, the idea that consumers direct markets through their choices. A threat to leave only disciplines a provider if customers are able and willing to carry it out.

How Has the FCA Responded?

The FCA’s final report on the market, published in March 2019, concluded that competition was generally working well but that some consumers and advisers found it difficult to shop around and switch because of the time, complexity and cost involved.

Its response was a form of competition policy aimed at the barriers themselves. New rules allowed investors to move platforms and keep the same fund without having to sell, while industry groups worked on speeding up transfers.

The FCA also consulted on banning exit fees. In November 2020 it stopped that work, saying there had been a marked shift in the market away from exit fees since its 2018 interim report. Regulatory pressure, in other words, changed provider behaviour without the need for a formal ban.

Why Does the First Choice of Platform Matter?

Switching costs mean the decision made when opening an account carries more weight than it first appears. A platform that is slightly more expensive at the start can become much more expensive over the years an investor stays.

Comparing providers on total charges, account types, transfer policies and regulatory status before opening an account reduces search costs at the point when changing direction is cheapest. Checking that a provider is authorised on the FCA register also matters, as protection for investors depends on the firm being properly regulated.

The broader implication extends outside of investment. If switching costs are high, how well the marketplace operates is largely dependent on what customers choose first and what information is available at the time of their decision-making.